SECS Electrical ☎ Call or text 0480 010 716
← Back to articles

I've Never Bought a New Car in My Life. So Why Am I Leasing an Electric One?

I have always bought second-hand cars and run them into the ground. Now I have signed for a new electric car I have not even sat in. The reason is kilometres, not a love of cars.

I've never bought a brand-new car in my life. I normally buy a second-hand one, drive it until it has just about had enough, and get another. I also hate working on cars. So how did I end up signing finance papers for a BYD Dolphin Premium without even sitting in one? It started with the cost of getting to work.

It started with the kilometres

I travel roughly 200 kilometres a day for work. That adds up rather quickly, and it means transport is a substantial ongoing expense whether I like it or not.

My Holden Cruze uses around 7.7 litres of petrol per 100 kilometres. At 200 kilometres a day that is about 15.4 litres. At $2 a litre it is $30.80 per working day, $616 over 20 working days, or $7,392 over 240 working days. Those are illustrative figures, not a prediction of the petrol price or exactly how many days I will drive.

That is just petrol. There is also servicing, tyres, registration, insurance and the occasional repair. I do not need a fancy car. I need a reliable way to cover kilometres without spending a fortune.

Why a novated lease even entered the picture

Normally I would not consider financing a brand-new car. I have always bought second-hand cars, driven them until they were just about finished, and bought another one.

But an eligible electric car on a novated lease can have favourable fringe benefits tax treatment. That made it worth doing the sums rather than dismissing it outright.

A novated lease is not a free car. There are finance charges, deductions from pay, running costs in the package and a residual amount to deal with at the end. The comparison has to be the whole cost against what I would otherwise spend, not just whether a fortnightly deduction looks reasonable.

Petrol versus electricity

Petrol is fairly easy to understand. I fill the tank and the money disappears. Electricity needs a bit more thought because the price depends on where and when the car is charged.

We have solar at home, so some charging may use surplus generation. Other charging could be on off-peak power at night, or occasionally at a public charger. Solar is not automatically free: energy used in the car may otherwise have been exported. Charging losses matter too.

The calculation needs realistic electricity prices, actual consumption and the occasions when charging does not happen under ideal conditions. A beautiful spreadsheet is no use if it assumes every kilometre is powered by free sunshine.

I was solving the wrong problem

I got myself worried about Anita taking the electric car on a long trip and getting home too late for it to be ready for my 200-kilometre commute the next morning.

Then I realised I was asking the wrong question. If Anita does 400 kilometres in the electric car and I do 200 in the petrol car, we have replaced 400 petrol kilometres. If I insist on taking the electric car for my 200 kilometres and she uses petrol for 400, we have only replaced 200 petrol kilometres.

Provided the electric kilometres are cheaper overall, the first arrangement may be the better result. The objective is not to make sure I always drive the electric car. It is to replace as many expensive petrol kilometres as practical.

Why the BYD Dolphin Premium?

I did not choose a Dolphin because I have always wanted one. I have not even sat in one yet, and the finance papers are already signed.

I looked for a practical electric car that could do the daily kilometres and make sense under the lease. The BYD Dolphin Premium appeared to fit that job. Whether I enjoy driving it is something I will find out later.

I will happily work on radios, computers, electrical equipment and machinery, but I hate working on cars. Even fitting a radio or gadget can become a fight with plastic trim and hidden clips. This car is not a new hobby. It is a kilometre replacement machine.

The numbers still have to prove themselves

There is a danger with any big decision: once you have decided what you want, it is easy to make the figures agree with you. I do not want to do that.

The car will depreciate, the lease has costs and the residual will have to be dealt with. I still need to find out what electricity consumption, charging costs, tyres and reliability look like in the real world.

Someone with a short commute, no convenient home charging or different financial circumstances might reach a completely different conclusion. This is how I approached my own decision, not advice that everybody should sign a novated lease.

Have I made the right decision?

Ask me after I have put some serious kilometres on the Dolphin. For now the paperwork is signed, the car is on order, and I am waiting to see whether the calculations turn into actual savings.

I have never bought a new car before. I have never even sat in a BYD Dolphin. And I do not particularly like cars. But I do like numbers. For once, the numbers might have talked me into getting a new one.

In Short

This is not an EV sales pitch and it is not proof that a novated lease is right for everyone. It is the story of someone who has always bought second-hand cars doing the sums and deciding that, for a long commute, a new electric car might make financial sense. The real test starts when it arrives.

Considering an EV for a long commute? Work through your own total costs, including the lease residual and realistic charging prices. I will report back when I have real kilometres and charging figures.

Small job, EV charger, rural electrical or something completely odd.

☎ Call or text 0480 010 716